Pirates Boathouse Café — Cafe in Elmira

Reviews of Pirates Boathouse Café

• Jacob

  Added 2014.12.19

  Exactly what we expected. The place looks like nothing but the food.... The food is awesome! Lobster mac n cheese was delicious and the scallop roll is worth the detour.
• Jason

  Added 2014.11.07

  Went with the server's favourite and ordered the lobster mac 'n cheese. It was delicious! Definitely worth a stop and only minutes from East Point lighthouse.
• Jesus

  Added 2014.04.08

  I loved this place. Great food prepared and served by friendly, down to earth people! We had the scallop dinner and the lobster roll with a delicious coleslaw followed by Apple pie with caramel sauce and it was all tasty! Stayed at the motel next door and went back and had breakfast and coffee the next day. If I was still in the area, I'd be there today!
• Nicholas

  Added 2014.02.18

  Great homemade island food. We had pan-fried scallops, homemade chowder and biscuits, lobster rolls, baked halibut & BLUEFIN TUNA! The food is locally sourced and the greens even came from an organic farmer down the road. It's a gem.
• Jack

  Added 2013.06.26

  What a treat! Fresh local blue fin tuna seared to perfection. Local organic veggies. Homemade carrot cake. And great atmosphere. Fishermen talking about their exciting days in rough seas. The owners talking local fishery history. And our waitress is one of 34,000 Inuktitut people. You can't beat this!